Tree of Life

18 Mar

1st Week of Pitt Spring Ball

published in category: College Sports on Friday, March 18th, 2016 – 9:16 am

When James Conner plays for Pitt this fall, it will be the biggest story in Pittsburgh Sports. Plus interview with Offensive Lineman Brian O’Neill. And preview of Pitt vs. Wisconsin.

318pittf

Pitt Release-
Coach Pat Narduzzi Quote Sheet
Opening statement:
“We got day two in. We’ve got our second of three total practices where we have to be in shorts, and we’ll get one in a couple weeks on a Monday after Easter after we come back. So we’ll put the big boy pads on next. I think our guys are looking forward to it. We had some physicality out there today. I guess our guys want to put the pads on, so we had to send someone on some laps today to keep them in line. But our guys were very energetic. Our kids are just so fired up. It just seems like there’s just so much energy out there to learn and to do the right things, so we’re excited where we are as of [today].”
On team energy during the second practice:
“I think the second day is always much better than the first day. I think the first day you’re just trying to see what they do. On the first day you’re just waiting to see what they’re going to do. And then I think as coaches I’m always more excited for the second day than I am for the first day. But the second day, you’re looking for them to get better. You know what they did yesterday, so you’re just looking to push buttons and get them ready for the next day. I didn’t think they were quiet at all today. I didn’t have to re-call them up and get them ready to go at all. That’s kind of their ‘M.O.’ They’ve been ready to go.”
On linebacker Mike Caprara:
“I think, last year, he was trying to find himself, and I think now he knows who he is and what he’s done, and I think he’s ready for the next level. We’re out there in the last period, and he recognizes something within our formations, and he barked it out. And I yelled out to [defensive coordinator] Coach [Josh] Conklin and [linebackers] Coach [Rob] Harley and said ‘Hey, you’ve got one guy who’s telling people what’s going on,’ which is good to see because I’m just listening to what he was saying and I knew the play because I had the paper [script] on me and he was 100 percent correct. He saw what the offense was doing. And he only saw it one other time, that they lined up in a formation package and he said, ‘Hey, watch the [name of given package and play].’ He’s got the ability to do a lot of different things, and I’ll take those smart guys. He does a great job.”
On the versatility of his linebackers:
“We’re going to find the best three guys, without a doubt. There’s enough versatility where we’re going to make it that way. But we’re always going to find the three best linebackers, and then who’s the fourth, who moves in for the fifth, and then sixth. You hope to have six or seven. I’ve gone through a season having four or five. You like to have seven that are some good special teams guys but we’ll be OK. We’ve got some guys who are banged up. We’re just being smart to not put them through contact stuff right now because we don’t have to beat anybody in May. They’ll be good to go in fall camp.”
On contact during spring practices:
“My philosophy on contact is to have as much as you can. [My philosophy] hasn’t changed at all. The game is a contact game. If you coach it in any other way, you’re losing something. It’s not basketball, it’s not soccer. It’s football. You’ve got to have contact, but you’ve got to coach it the right way. You can’t have cheap shots. You can’t have players with their heads down who are going to get hurt or hurt somebody else. It hasn’t changed, and we’re going to get in as much contact as we can. When the NCAA says we can tackle, then we tackle.”
On moving Jalen Williams and Seun Idowu to linebacker from defensive back:
“It’s a permanent thing. As a matter of fact, Seun was moved down probably halfway through the season last year just to get him ready to go. Seun didn’t come into camp last year. I wish he would have. He missed a lot of practices. But that’s a permanent move for both of them (Williams and Idowu). Both of them will show improvement, and both of them probably showed improvement today. I’m interested in seeing where they are after 15. I think it’s a good move for both of those kids.”
On wide receiver Tre Tipton:
“First of all he’s a great kid. He’s smart. He’s got a lot of swagger to him. I think it starts there. He’s got a ton of athletic ability. I think he’s going to be a great player for us. I think when you watch the spring game on the 16th, I think you’re going to say, ‘Woah, who’s that [jersey] number two.” I keep telling him that it’s about being tough. You’ve got to make it through the 15 days. One of our goals is to get all 15 practices in. You can’t get better with the yellow jersey on. If he gets through 15 that means he’s mentally and physically toughened up and able to make it through, but I think he can do big things. He’s explosive, he’s got great hands, he runs great routes, he can get off the press. He’s a great football player and he needs to show it on the field.”
On having a wider distribution of touches among the receivers this year now that Tyler Boyd is gone:
“I think it happens naturally. I think it goes with the part of offense of what you’re trying to do, who you’re trying to get it to, what your run game is like and how your offense is set up. The offense is a little bit different from what it was last year, not much different. We try to keep a lot of things the same, so we’ll see. We like to get the guys the ball, and you demand reps and snaps and catches by doing your job. And, obviously, Tyler is a guy who we targeted a lot and handed the ball off to because he demanded those. He worked for those because he knew that, once he got the ball in his hands, he’d do something with it or he’d catch it. Guys have to prove that they want the ball and should get the ball.”
On having untested options at wide receiver:
“I don’t think it’s in bad shape at all. As a matter of fact, I’m pretty excited with what I’ve seen over the last two days. But I always think that. In shorts, receivers catch the ball really well. I think the big time is when they’re going to get hit, whether they’re going to get hit immediately or later. Once the pads go on, you can really tell who can play.”
On Tyler Boyd’s pro timing day:
“Tyler had a great pro day. He actually had another workout this morning with the Carolina Panthers and did a great job out there, didn’t run a 40 or anything. Tyler really needed to come in here—and I don’t watch ESPN for the combine, but I watched bits and pieces of it—but he put on eight pounds before the combine. Most guys usually lose weight. J.P. [Holtz] yesterday was down weight. Artie Rowell probably lost about 12 pounds. Everybody loses weight so they can run a faster 40 time for the combine. So he put on weight, and he wasn’t necessarily worried about the 40. So that’s a good thing. He’s more worried about playing football and he’s a great football player. I think he made some money yesterday by going out there and running the 40, which is all that he had to do. And then when you watch his ball skills and him work out, he’s special catching the ball. You can hardly hear the ball touching his hands.”
On the performance of other Pitt players on pro timing day:
“There’s a lot of guys out there. Nicholas Grigsby. You look at Lafayette Pitts, who had a great day yesterday. I could mention a lot of them. David Murphy did a great job of snapping. J.P. Holtz as well. There’s a lot of guys out there who will find their ways to camp. Will they make it? Will they get drafted? I don’t know. I don’t sit in on the personnel meetings. Some guys chose to stay here with [Pitt strength and conditioning] Coach [Dave] Andrews and really did well, and some guys chose to get trainers across the country and enjoy the sun, but I was impressed with all of them and what they looked like.”
On recent communication with NFL scouts and coaches:
“Yeah, you get phone calls, and a lot of them will save the comments for when they get here and watch them and do a face-to-face, but you never know.”

Defensive Coordinator Josh Conklin Quote Sheet
On observations after two days:
“We have a long way to go, I know that. I feel like we’ve had really good effort right now and the guys have been trying hard to do what we want them to do. However, in terms of what we want to do defensively, we’ve got a long way to go right now.”
On injuries at the linebacker position:
“It’s got to be the next guy up. We have a converted safety in Jalen Williams coming down to play the Star, and another converted safety in Oluwaseun Idowu playing Star. It’s going to be a bit of a painful process this spring in term of getting those guys to play at the level we want them to play at. It’s obviously a bit of a concern, as well as depth for us. We want to get some guys healthy but it’s a great opportunity for some of the younger guys to develop at some really important positions.”
On moving Shakir Soto from end to tackle:
“We need to become more athletic at the defensive tackle position. We didn’t get the production we needed from those guys, especially on the inside. It’s a major focus and major emphasis for us. We lost a couple guys in there that were decent players for us. We feel like he will give us more athleticism in there, but we have to get more production from those guys as it’ll help us in the run game. It’s not where it needs to be.”
On the balance between installation of new things and focusing on improvement:
“We don’t put in a bunch of new stuff, it’s more of making what we have better. We’ve put in some adjustments, but in terms of all that our guys are just in the second year of the system getting more comfortable with it. Their attitude and effort in doing so has been really good.”
On safety Jordan Whitehead’s potential going forward:
“You would hope it would be a lot in terms of his improvement. He has a lot of natural skill and he played off of that last year. The big thing for him is making everything tighter, his keys tighter, and his reads tighter, where everything slows down for him. With that, we hope he will be more productive going forward.”
On the versatility and leadership of linebacker Mike Caprara:
“He will probably line up under all three positions in the spring. He can play the Mike, the Money and the Star. He’s at Money right now. He and Matt Galambos have done a really good job leading it, especially from the linebacker position, which is where you really want it as far as making the calls and the checks. He’s been really good.”
On defensive end Dewayne Hendrix looking ready to contribute this year:
“He looks like a Division I college football player. He’s an SEC defensive end. When you look out there, there’s a marked difference in terms of what he looks like. That’s what they look like. For me, as far as getting the depth and the guys we need to get, that’s what you want them to be. Speed matters, strength, power, and all that. Our job is to get him there and hopefully he will. He’s got all the skill sets to be an important player for us, schematically as well.”
On depth at defensive end:
“When Rori Blair gets back I think it’ll be good, and Dewayne Hendrix is a good addition to that. We need to develop some of the younger guys like James Folston. He has to come along. The biggest thing with those interior guys right now and even the defensive ends is playing with an attitude. Getting a relentless attitude that we want to play with. Getting an energy and a knowledge of the game, and we’re getting there.”

Wide Receiver Tre Tipton Quote Sheet
On his first spring practice:
“The first spring practice was really good. As a team we worked really hard. Came off really fast and going into a new system everybody is catching on really easily. I feel like we’re going to be pretty good this year.”
On the receiving corps without Tyler Boyd:
“Honestly, personally, I see us as we’re about to be the next best receiving corps. Everybody was looking at Tyler Boyd, but our goal next year is you can’t guard any of us. If you want to double team me, or Jester Weah or Quadree Henderson, it’s going to be tough for you because we have other people working inside the system. It’s not so much who’s the next Tyler Boyd or Larry Fitzgerald, it’s going to be who’s the best receiving corps and we feel like we are.”
On the possibility of more targets throughout the receiving corps:
“It makes everything exciting to be honest with you. We saw how fast the ball is moving and everybody is getting a chance to get the ball. It seems like everyone can do something with the ball in their hands and is feeling more comfortable. Now everybody is going out there and doing what we’re supposed to do and what we should have done last year. Now that Tyler Boyd is gone, he’s gone but he still comes back and pushes us to get better. It’s going to be interesting.”
On how he feels this year compared to last year in training camp:
“I feel so much more comfortable. It feels like everything has slowed down and the teammates that we have make it feel easy. Everything this year is a lot easier than last year and the pace of it is easier. I’m starting to learn more football, not just going off of athleticism but football I.Q. now. Learning the schemes and reading the coverage, it’s all become a lot easier.”
On his strengths as a wide receiver:
“I’m getting really good at reading the cornerback and the safety. I’m not the fastest guy on the team but I feel like I’m one of the [sharpest] guys. I can see something, coach will tell me something, and I kind of like to make it my own. I like to call myself a chemist like I work in a lab or something. I try to learn and then make it my own.”
On the message Tyler Boyd gave to the receivers:
“Compete. Go out there and compete, and win. Everybody knows Tyler is a hard worker, but he’s also the best competitor I’ve ever met. So he tells us to go out there and compete, and not only compete but win. That’s the game plan. We can’t let him down. Everybody is asking what we’re going to do without Tyler. If we don’t live up to that standard and look past that standard, then we’re letting him down. We plan on living up to that standard and surpassing that standard. We need to make sure that everybody knows that even though we don’t have Tyler we’re still ready to go out there and handle our business.”
On senior receiver Dontez Ford:
“Dontez is definitely a leader. He’s an old guy, he’s been around a long time and he’s the only one of us that actually started last year. Learning how he takes care of business is a big opportunity for us and a big way for us to learn from him.”

Defensive End Dewayne Hendrix Quote Sheet
On sitting out the 2015 season following his transfer:
“Starting off it was pretty tough, but I just had to look at the bigger picture. I know it would make me better. It feels good just getting back. I have a lot of work to do. We’re still working.”
On why Pitt is a better fit for him than Tennessee:
“Mainly the coaches and the defense that we run, I feel like I will be better here. It’s a lot easier playing a nine technique rather than a six technique. Six technique is a lot harder with your head up, while as a nine you’re outside and basically just have to contain.”
On his development over the past year:
“I feel like I’ve got a lot better. I feel a lot more comfortable out there as well.”
On what his motivation was over the last year:
“I just had to look at it like I had to help the team. I couldn’t look at it like I’m not playing so I’m about to just go fifty percent instead of one hundred percent. I know if I gave my all it would help the offense and help the team, and that’s all I want to do.”
On why he chose Pitt:
“When I decided to transfer, I didn’t know where I wanted to go. A good buddy of mine, quarterback Nate Peterman played a big part in it. As I started to take more and more visits here, I really started to like the place.”

Posted in College Sports

 

17 Mar

Don’t doubt Conner

published in category: College Sports on Thursday, March 17th, 2016 – 2:25 pm


Posted in College Sports

 

17 Mar

“Steelers Mock Draft 1.0: The Trend Finally Ends,” by Josh Taylor

published in category: Pittsburgh Steelers on Thursday, March 17th, 2016 – 1:29 am

217combine

With the moves the Steelers have made so far in free agency, they have filled every need on the offense, allowing them to put their focus on improving their defense in what General Manager Kevin Colbert is calling “a strong defensive draft.” With seven picks this year, they have an opportunity to build depth in certain areas and possibly find starters in others.

1st Round, 25th overall: William Jackson III, Cornerback, Houston – This could be the year the Steelers finally end their drought and pick a corner in the first round — not because it’s what fans want, but because Jackson fits what the team needs. He out-shined top-rated defensive back Jalen Ramsey in the Peach Bowl against Florida State with 10 tackles and two interceptions. He ran the 40-yard dash in 4.37 seconds at the Scouting Combine and caught everyone’s attention with the best time for a corner. He’s physical, fast, and a play-maker, just what the Steelers need on the boundary.

2nd Round, 58th overall: Keanu Neal, Safety, Florida – Neal is a top-50 talent and a potential second-round steal. He’s a quick-twitch player with good downhill explosion and he finishes tackles. He’s played near the line of scrimmage and as a single high safety, which is the kind of versatility the Steelers like from their safeties. Has good enough athleticism, instincts and play-making ability to start right away, but if not, he can make an immediate impact on special teams. His personal character has been noted among scouts and his personality showed through in a recent interview on TribLive Radio. With his talent and personality he’s a young man Steelers fans will love from Day One.

3rd Round, 89th overall: Pharoh Cooper, Wide Receiver, South Carolina – The Steelers need a kick returner and some depth at wide receiver with Martavis Bryant’s one-year suspension. Cooper provides both, along with a combination of maturity and discipline from growing up in a military family that wouldn’t be unwelcome. He would also bring the same kind of flash to the running game Bryant did, having earned second-team All-SEC honors as an all-purpose back in 2014. He’s short, but well-built (5-foot-11, 203 lbs.) and has early special teams value with a strong long-term potential as a slot receiver.

4th Round, 124th overall: Deiondre’ Hall, Cornerback, Northern Iowa – He has below average speed (4.68 40-yd dash), but great size (6-foot-2). He has 34 3/8-inch arms, long enough help him on those 50/50 balls in the air and break up passes. He fits the William Gay mold of using his instincts well and using them to make plays on the ball in the air. He had six interceptions in 2015 (most in the Missouri Valley Conference) and returned two of them for touchdowns. He has experience playing both cornerback and safety and he’s not afraid to play bump-and-run on receivers or stick his “face in the fan” in run support.

6th Round, 221st overall: Victor Ochi, Edge Rusher, Stony Brook – He’s slower and smaller than the ideal pass rusher (6-foot-1, 246 lbs.), but he’s strong with a nasty disposition and loves contact. He can make plays in the backfield against the run and the pass, and he has good arm length to get extension and fight off blockers at the point of attack. But he’s a long-term project as he will have to learn to catch up with the speed of the pro game and learn to survive against better talent than at the FCS level, plus he has very poor coverage skills and he’s limited in space. If he can refine his counter moves and snap anticipation, maybe he can carve a niche as a situational pass-rusher.

7th Round, 230th overall: Jonathan Williams, Running Back, Arkansas – His draft position will be a lot lower than it should because he missed the entire 2015 season with a foot injury. He didn’t run the 40-yard dash at the Combine, but he clocked in the high 4.5’s at Arkansas’ Pro Day this week. He’s strong and thick with light feet that help him move well laterally and make the first defender miss. He has excellent patience and instincts through the hole that allow him to gain yards on the same kind of “power” and “counter” plays the Steelers have run so successfully with Le’Veon Bell. He’s competent enough in pass protection and out in the route that he’s a legitimate three-down back who could eventually replace DeAngelo Williams as Bell’s backup or a no. 2 in a time share situation.

7th Round, 247th overall: Joel Heath, Defensive Tackle, Michigan State – He switched from defensive end to defensive tackle midway through his career and started for two seasons on the interior. He has a good motor and doesn’t give up pursuit of the ball carrier. He’s capable of playing in an even or odd front, but he still needs to improve on his technique to give Cameron Heyward and Stephon Tuitt a spell as a backup. He projects as a solid candidate for defensive line coach John Mitchell to mold into a rotational guy with some long-term value.

Posted in Pittsburgh Steelers

 

16 Mar

Pitt Pro Day by Ken Laird

published in category: College Sports on Wednesday, March 16th, 2016 – 2:50 pm

Ken Laird and Jerry Dipaola live from Pitt Pro Day on Tyler Boyd improving his draft stock. Then hear from Tyler Boyd, KK Mosley-Smith, Darryl Render and JP Holtz in that order on their Pro Days.

316boyd

Pitt held their annual football Pro Timing Day at the UPMC Sports Performance Complex on Wednesday, with several NFL teams represented.

Working out for Pitt were: WR Tyler Boyd, LB Nicholas Grigsby, TE J.P. Holtz, DL Khaynin Mosley-Smith, LS David Murphy, DB Lafayette Pitts, DL Darryl Render, and OL Artie Rowell.

Boyd, the marquee attraction with the highest NFL draft stock, only participated in the 40-yard draft and individual position skill work (route running). According to Boyd, he ran under a 4.50 40-yard dash, somewhere in the “4.46 or 4.47” range. At the NFL Combine, Boyd ran a time of 4.58 that he admitted he was disappointed in.

316boyd3

Hand times at Pro Days from the various scouts in attendance ranged from 4.47 to 4.51 according to a source, with one scout saying he had Boyd at 4.51 and 4.56.

Boyd looked smooth in the route running, catching balls from former Pitt quarterback Trey Anderson.

Also drawing some buzz from scouts were Grigsby and Pitts for their various times, although none were made official.

The stations for testing included the vertical jump, broad jump, pro shuttle, three-cone drill, and 60-yard shuttle in addition to the 40-yard dash.

316boyd2

Posted in College Sports

 

16 Mar

RMU vs. Army

published in category: College Sports on Wednesday, March 16th, 2016 – 1:44 pm

Head Coach Derek Schooley joins Tim Benz and Josh Taylor to preview game vs. Army, win and the Colonials move on the the Finals and a chance to earn a spot in the NCAA Tournament.

316rmu

Robert Morris University men’s hockey senior forward Zac Lynch has been named a top 10 finalist for the Hobey Baker Award, the highest honor awarded in men’s NCAA hockey.

Lynch presently leads all active players in career scoring with 153 career points (tied with two others), averaging 1.02 points per game of the course of his career (66 G – 87 A – 153 P). The Pittsburgh native is tied for second in the NCAA in scoring with 52 points on 24 goals and 28 assists, and is the Atlantic Hockey scoring champion.

Lynch broke the Robert Morris program scoring record with his 151st career point. Lynch has scored eight shorthanded goals this season, most by any current player, and holds the Robert Morris program record with 14 shorthanded goals in his career. Lynch scored a shorthanded goal in four consecutive games this season (11/20 & 11/21 vs. Army and 11/27 & 11/28 vs. Sacred Heart.

Lynch has skated in every game this season as the right winger on the Colonials top line. There have been just three games during the 2015-16 season in which Lynch did not record a point. Lynch has tallied 13 multi-point games this season and has posted three-points games five times. Lynch was named Three Rivers Classic tournament MVP after scoring three goals, helping the Colonials beat No. 14 Penn State and No. 8 UMass-Lowell. Lynch is part of the Colonials power play, ranked number one in the nation throughout much of the season and currently fourth in the NCAA, converting at a 28.8 percent clip.

Lynch is among the best career performers active in college hockey. Zac is among the top ten nationally in four categories: Points (153 points, 1st), Goals (66 Goals, 4th), Assists (87 Assists, 4th), Shorthanded Goals (14 SHG, 1st). Lynch is also 11th in power play goals with 18 and tied for 30th in game-winning goals with eight.

Lynch is the second Robert Morris hockey player to be a top ten finalist for the Hobey Baker, following Cody Wydo ’15 who was in the top ten last season. Lynch’s fellow seniors Greg Gibson and Brandon Denham were also nominees this year.

Lynch is the first Pittsburgh area native to be named a top ten finalist since Plum’s R.J. Umberger, now with the Philadelphia Flyers, was a finalist for Ohio State in 2003.

The second phase of fan balloting will run March 17-27 (top ten candidates only).The Hobey Hat Trick (three finalists) will be announced on March 31, 2016 and the Hobey Baker Award winner will be announced Friday, April 8, 2016 from Tampa, FL during the NCAA Frozen Four. The award announcement will take place at the historic Tampa Theatre, built in 1926 as one of America’s most elaborate movie palaces. The announcement will be televised live on the NHL Network and can be followed on the Hobey Baker website at 6:00 p.m. ET.

Complete list of top ten finalists: JT Compher, Michigan, Kyle Connor, Michigan, Thatcher Demko, Boston College, Zac Lynch, Robert Morris, Alex Lyon, Yale, Tyler Motte, Michigan, Alex Petan, Michigan Tech, Andrew Poturalski, New Hampshire, Ethan Prow, St. Cloud State, Jimmy Vesey, Harvard.

Posted in College Sports

 

16 Mar

Madness of March

published in category: College Sports on Wednesday, March 16th, 2016 – 9:37 am


Posted in College Sports

 

15 Mar

RAW in PGH

published in category: Wrestling Reality on Tuesday, March 15th, 2016 – 2:24 pm


Posted in Wrestling Reality

 

15 Mar

IGNORE THE SMALL CONFERENCE SOB STORIES by Tim Benz

published in category: College Sports on Tuesday, March 15th, 2016 – 8:48 am

I hate to say it, but Cinderella has zits.

Now that we’ve spent 30 years sandblasting away the make up, those NCAA small-conference-upset gals getting out of the pumpkin carriages aren’t as charming as they used to be.

It’s not their fault mind you. No one is as pretty as you thought when you are looking at the pores of their skin through a magnifying glass as opposed to the soft white light of the NCAA tournament stage.

And it’s tough to keep up with naturally nice features when the evil step-sisters are pumping up with silicone and botox laced conference scheduling.

But in the days since the brackets have been unveiled a river of tears has been cried for the mid majors/small conference schools while the mean, nasty Power 5 colleges have soaked up a lot of the at large spots.

If you are looking for sympathy for the Monmouth’s, St. Mary’s and St. Bonaventures of the world, go elsewhere. You’ll get none here.

These lesser-conference schools have been left out for a reason…they play in lesser conferences. It’s that simple.

Yet their fan bases want to have it both ways. Their fans want their teams to be evaluated on the same level as the Power-5 reps. But they want the pity party when the math doesn’t work out in their favor.

Fans of those schools are mad at Syracuse, Vanderbilt, and Michigan for getting bids they feel should be distributed to them. They’re blaming the wrong institutions. Instead, they should be blaming Gonzaga, Northern Iowa, Butler, Harvard and Princeton.

Because over the years those colleges helped forge the very reputation of this tournament as being the magnificent made for TV event that it has become by emerging from lesser known conferences with really good squads. With no reputation and limited committee research, they were seeded poorly and often upset second tier entrants from the bigger conferences who were slotted in the 2-7 seed range.

So what happened? Those schools complained. “Why are we always slotted so poorly when we keep performing well every year?”

What else happened? The bigger conference schools complained even louder. “Why are those schools slotted so low when they keep upsetting us in the first round?! They are making us look bad!”
Eventually, those schools started to get ranked in the polls. They got elevated from small conferences to mid-major conferences when the Power 5’s expanded. The playing field started to square.

In theory, progress was being made. The whole time, all we heard from the mid majors and small conferences was-”Judge us like the big schools! Create balanced points of evaluation for selection Sunday. Don’t go by the jersey. Go by the data.”

RPI replaced AP. SOS suddenly became a good thing and not a distress signal from boat.

Unfortunately this year, the lesser lights saw the other side of the coin. Once we get away from the crazy bench antics of Monmouth, and the noble records of St. Bonaventure & St. Mary’s, why are we upset these schools got left out exactly?

Disclaimer here. Yup. I went to Syracuse. And after their third loss of the season to PITT in the ACC tournament, I was disgusted enough to write them off for the NIT. Until I realized in this parody addled season, who should really knock them off the bubble?

Wanna compare them to the smaller conference feel goods who were allegedly ticketed for the tourney “on a fair and balanced” level?

Yeah, let’s do that.

Monmouth is everyone’s snub sob story because they tried to schedule hard. The operative word is “tried.” Unfortunately for the Hawks, it didn’t work out. Georgetown ended up being poor. So did UCLA. Nice try. But those wins don’t mean as much as you hoped. And they don’t mean as much as Syracuse also beating UCONN and Texas A&M out of conference (and Duke in conference). The Hawks’ best win is Notre Dame (who Syracuse also beat). Their second best win is USC (who, in a scheduling rarity, previously beat them). They have three sub RPI 150 losses. Syracuse has one.

309artis

All that means is what Syracuse did out of conference was rated at 122 in the country. Monmouth rates at 129. So is the mythical “well Monmouth tried to schedule better” argument worth nine slots of data? And are we just going to apply the data when/where it is convenient to the sob story argument?

Oh by the way, Syracuse played in the ACC. Monmouth plays in the MAAC. And their second best competition in that conference (Iona) beat them twice.

So how about St.Bonnies then, right? Well Syracuse did schedule them. And they beat the Bonnies by 13. They’re best out of conference win was against Ohio. Meanwhile, St. Mary’s lost it’s only non conference game in the top 50 RPI to Cal.

Vanderbilt, Oregon State, and even Michigan can also make similar arguments against them on different points similar to those from the Orange.

Is it inequitable that these teams have a harder time scheduling out of conference opponents? Yes. Does the system cater towards the bigger conference? Indeed. Should the selection committee depart from the system it established simply in the name of altruism for the smaller conference schools?

No it shouldn’t. Because if the argument to do so is to set up more crazy Cinderella upsets, then ask this question: Are you really a Cinderella if you are good enough to get an at large bid in the first place?

So if the message from the small conference schools is “see us for who we are”, then don’t be surprised when the wicked step sisters get to wear the slippers.

Posted in College Sports

 



Podcasts